Next Meeting: 8th December at 6:30pm to discuss My Friends by Hisham Matar.
There are Rivers in the Sky by Elif Shafak. This is a complex, historical interrelated novel raising a number of issues and themes.
The book covers 4 stories:
- Nineveh, King Ashurbanipal and the Epic of Gilgamesh…the oldest poem in the world.
- King Arthur of the Sewers and Slums. Arthur Smyth, a gifted boy from the slums of London, is based on the life of George Smith, who decoded cuneiform and translated the Epic of Gilgamesh. The book traces his life from the slums, through his self education to the sites of Nineveh. This story brings in real characters, Dr John Snow who made the lie between cholera and drinking water, Charles Dickens, who was published by Bradbury and Evans.
- Zaleekah a hydrologist in contemporary London who is redefining herself after a failed marriage.
- Narin, a Yazidi child whose grandmother wants her to follow the age old traditions of the Yazidi and her persecution at the hands of ISIS in 2014.
A number of themes are covered in the book. The concept of water memory in raindrops and the journey of one raindrop over time.
Also addressed are the issues of pollution in London and Paris in 19C and London in the 21C , environmental degradation on rivers, and the consequences of dam building.
Human rights issues addressed in the book include Yazidi persecution in Iraq, at the hands of ISIS, refugees and their relocation, slavery and black market organ harvesting.
Cultural theft (appropriation) which can lead to artefact purchases by the rich, or wealthy institutions, and the issue associated with lost traditions were also raised.
Public reception and reviews praised the book’s rich thematic scope, lyrical prose and high profile acclaim for the ambitious scale of the book and its exploration of the ownership of history and cultural artefacts. On the other hand the book has been described as having a baggy plot, over research and tenuous thematic ties. Uneven characterisation and cloying sentimentalism were also directed at the writing.
Members of Book Lovers found the book long, over researched, ambitious, but bogged down with ideas and detail. Some members identified that the division of stories made the book difficult to read. The book started well and the stories of Nineveh and Arthur of the Slums were interesting, and well received, Zaleeka’s story somewhat unnecessary, and Narin’s journey very confronting.
Ratings: Sandy 2.5, Kim 2.5, Hetta 4, Dianne 3, Lesley 3, Janet 3, Veronica 3, Lynda 2.5, Margie 2.5, Dianne F 3, Jenny 4
We look forward to seeing you again at our next meeting at 6.30pm, Tuesday 8th of December
to discuss My Friends by Hisham Matar.
About Us
We are a group that gets together once a month to discuss good books. Each of us gets to choose a book on a rotational basis, preferably one outside our personal comfort zone – we try to keep the trash to ourselves. After the discussion, we comment on other books we read that month. Most of the time we remain friends after the meeting.
We normally meet at Room 2.1 of the Robina Community Centre’s Boadroom. This building is located opposite the Auditorium entrance of the Robina Library on the second Tuesday of every month from 6:30 p.m. to 8:30 p.m.
A small contribution is required towards the rent of the room, but not if you are a first timer. The amount depends on the number of people attending.
One book title is chosen each month and we all read that book. There is a ‘host’ who introduces and co-ordinates the discussion. The role of host is rotated around the group so that each member has the opportunity to nominate their book (it could also be an author, theme or genre). The host also acts as chairperson for that meeting.
Although we are not a social club (we are readers), we occasionally attend literary events, relevant movies or plays here at the Gold Coast, Brisbane or Byron Bay. We conform to basic meeting practices, and everyone has an equal opportunity to express their opinion. Everyone’s interpretation is valid, as long as it’s expressed respectfully.
We welcome any new members who share our aims and are happy to contribute to our group. Newcomers are not required to have read the book to attend the first meeting and no contribution is required from them at the first meeting attended.
Feel free to have a look at our Book List and Newsletters in the sidebar. If you are reading this blog in a mobile device find the menu at the bottom of the page.
CONTACT DETAILS
For more information use the contact form.

